Raquel Rodriguez believes there was more to explore between herself and former Judgment Day member Carlito before his WWE exit brought their brief on-screen dynamic to an abrupt stop.
The Judgment Day has remained one of WWE’s most frequently evolving groups, with Liv Morgan, Dominik Mysterio, Rodriguez, JD McDonagh, and Roxanne Perez presently associated with the faction. Its roster has changed significantly over time, however, and Carlito’s departure in June 2025 removed a personality whose interactions with Rodriguez had suggested the possibility of a lighthearted side story.
Speaking on Insight with Chris Van Vliet, Rodriguez looked back on moments when her Judgment Day colleagues made it difficult to keep a straight face during television segments. That conversation led to Carlito and the flirtatious energy that occasionally appeared between the two performers. While the idea never became a major WWE angle, Rodriguez indicated that there had been discussion about finding out where it could lead.
“I don’t know [where that was going],” Rodriguez said on Insight with Chris Van Vliet. “I think we were trying to see where it was going to go. I did wish that we would’ve had a moment of — like, a final date or something, you know? That would’ve been fun.”
For more background on this topic, read Jeff Cobb Says WWE Considered JONAH Name Before His JC Mateo Debut.
Rodriguez’s comments underline the difference between an on-screen tease and a completed storyline. Wrestling television regularly introduces character beats that can be expanded, redirected, or dropped as creative plans change. In this case, Carlito’s occasional flirtation with Rodriguez gave Judgment Day segments an added comic element, but it did not ultimately develop into a defined angle with a clear ending.
For Rodriguez, a final date segment could have offered that conclusion. It would not necessarily have required a major match, betrayal, or dramatic split from the group. Instead, it could have been a small character moment that acknowledged the running joke and gave both performers a memorable closing scene. Those kinds of details can matter, particularly within a faction built around interpersonal tension, shifting loyalties, and personalities competing for attention.
Carlito’s Exit Left Several Threads Behind
Carlito’s second WWE run ended when he left the company in 2025. He later stated that his contract had expired, while also noting that he had been taken off WWE programming several weeks before the agreement reached its end. That sequence meant there was no substantial television write-off for his character, whether through a match, a direct faction confrontation, or a storyline explanation for his disappearance.
Rodriguez was not the only person who would have preferred a more conclusive sendoff. Carlito has said he also wanted an angle that would explain his exit rather than having his on-screen presence simply end. His time around Judgment Day included comedic contributions and supporting appearances during a period when the faction continued to be central to WWE storylines. Even so, his departure did not receive the type of formal resolution that often accompanies a featured character leaving a group.
That is why Rodriguez’s recollection stands out. Rather than framing the unused material as something that was guaranteed to happen, she described it as an idea that was being explored. The distinction is important. WWE’s creative process can involve performers discussing possibilities that never make it beyond the early stages. Rodriguez did not present the proposed final date as a booked segment that was cancelled at the last minute; she simply expressed that it would have been enjoyable to have one more moment with Carlito before he was gone.
Still, the fact that both performers have spoken about wanting some form of closure gives the unfinished thread a different context. Their interactions had a recognizable premise, and audiences were left without an answer as to whether the flirtation was meant to become a genuine romantic subplot, a continuing joke, or merely a short-lived part of the group’s comedy.
Rodriguez Has Not Ruled Out A Future Follow-Up
Despite the lack of a conclusion during Carlito’s latest run, Rodriguez does not view the door as permanently closed. Asked about the possibility of revisiting the concept, she offered an optimistic answer.
“Who knows? There’s hope for the future,” Rodriguez said on Insight with Chris Van Vliet.
That does not confirm any planned WWE return for Carlito or any revived program involving Rodriguez. There has been no indication that the company has scheduled such an angle. Rodriguez’s point was simply that professional wrestling is an environment where former performers and unresolved stories can return unexpectedly. A character who exits without a definitive television ending is, in theory, easier to reintroduce than someone who has been given an unmistakable farewell.
Carlito’s career itself illustrates how quickly circumstances can change. His 2025 departure was not his first time leaving WWE, and his return for a later run showed that past exits do not always prevent another chapter. Whether there is ever a third WWE stint, and whether Rodriguez remains connected to Judgment Day if that occurs, are entirely separate questions. But the lack of a decisive ending leaves room for fans to imagine a callback.
A future reunion would not need to replicate the original dynamic exactly. The passage of time and changing alignments could alter the context. Rodriguez is currently part of a Judgment Day lineup that includes Morgan, Mysterio, McDonagh, and Perez, while Carlito is no longer on the roster. If their paths crossed again, WWE could treat the old flirtation as a joke, turn it into a brief backstage segment, or build it into a more substantial character story. At present, however, those are only possibilities rather than announced plans.
The Value Of Character Closure In Factions
Judgment Day has long depended on more than match results. Its identity has been shaped by relationships inside the group: alliances, arguments, romantic connections, manipulation, power struggles, and sudden departures. That structure can create plenty of material, but it also means that roster changes sometimes leave smaller story points unresolved.
Rodriguez and Carlito’s interactions were not the faction’s main focus, yet they added texture to a group that often mixed serious conflict with comedy. Rodriguez’s comments suggest she appreciated that lighter side of the material. A final date, as she described it, could have provided a playful payoff without taking attention away from the larger developments involving the rest of Judgment Day.
Such closure can also serve the audience. Wrestling fans frequently remember minor details when they are rooted in distinctive character work. A quick return to an old gag can reward long-term viewers, especially if it acknowledges that a prior story never received an ending. At the same time, WWE has to balance those callbacks with the needs of its current roster and ongoing programs. The present version of Judgment Day has its own dynamics to develop, particularly with Rodriguez alongside Morgan, Mysterio, McDonagh, and Perez.
For now, Rodriguez’s remarks offer a look at a small piece of WWE creative that never fully reached the screen. There was interest in seeing where the Carlito material might go, but neither the flirtation nor his Judgment Day involvement received a final chapter before his contract ended. Rodriguez would have enjoyed one last on-screen date, Carlito has expressed disappointment over not receiving a proper exit angle, and the result is an intentionally or unintentionally open thread.
Whether that thread is ever picked up again remains unknown. Rodriguez has not claimed that a reunion is in the works, and Carlito’s WWE future has not been established. But in a company where returns and references to past stories are always possible, Rodriguez’s belief that there is “hope for the future” leaves the possibility alive.



