Jeff Cobb’s brief WWE run as JC Mateo could have unfolded under a very different identity. Cobb has revealed that, when WWE presented possible new ring names ahead of his debut at Backlash 2025, one suggestion immediately stood out for a surprising reason: JONAH.

The name was already closely associated with Bronson Reed, who had used JONAH during his post-release run in New Japan Pro-Wrestling and elsewhere before returning to WWE. Cobb said the inclusion of that name on his list made him question the process behind the options being offered to him.

Cobb, who has since left WWE and returned to NJPW, discussed the experience while looking back on the day of his WWE debut. He said the naming process began promisingly enough, with dozens of options that appeared to draw from elements of his personal background. The next page of suggestions, however, seemed much less tailored.

“The first page, I’ll say it was maybe 60 names on there. I was like okay, this is pretty cool, pretty cool,” Cobb said. “They’re trying to go into my background with Guam, my background in Hawaii. I was like, okay. Second page, I don’t know what happened. It just started doing random names. I was like, ‘How are they choosing this?’”

For more background on this topic, read Report: Joe Hendry Mentioned in WWE Discussions for Potential New Tag Teams.

Among the proposed names was “Jafar Smash,” an option that would have taken Cobb’s presentation in an entirely different direction. Yet it was JONAH, printed in all capital letters, that made him laugh.

“One that stuck out made me giggle because it was all caps, JONAH. [That had been used] by Bronson Reed. The guy that’s in your company. I was like, ‘Wait a minute, are you guys even trying now?’”

A Name With Recent WWE Connections

The proposed use of JONAH was notable because the identity had a clear and relatively recent connection to a WWE roster member. Before becoming known to many WWE viewers as Bronson Reed, the powerhouse wrestler competed on the independent scene as Jonah Rock. He joined WWE and became the inaugural NXT North American Champion under the Bronson Reed name, but his first WWE stint ended with his release in August 2021.

Following that departure, Reed adopted JONAH as his ring name. The persona became a major part of his work outside WWE, including appearances for NJPW, TNA, and PROGRESS. In New Japan especially, JONAH was positioned prominently and became familiar to fans who followed the promotion’s heavyweight scene.

Reed returned to WWE in December 2022 and resumed using the Bronson Reed name. That left JONAH as a name no longer being used on WWE television, but it remained strongly connected to someone actively employed by the company. Cobb’s reaction reflected that association. To him, it was not simply an unused name on a list; it was a name fans had recently heard from one of his prospective WWE colleagues.

There is no indication that Cobb seriously moved forward with JONAH, or that WWE intended to make the name its final choice. It was one of many possibilities shown to him during the process. Ultimately, WWE settled on JC Mateo for Cobb’s main-roster presentation.

From NJPW Standout to JC Mateo

Cobb arrived in WWE with a substantial body of work and a well-established reputation under his own name. A powerful amateur-style wrestler with an Olympic background, he had spent years building his profile across major international promotions. NJPW was a particularly important part of that journey, as Cobb originally wrestled there from 2017 until 2025.

His run in New Japan helped cement him as a credible heavyweight attraction. Cobb competed against leading names, took part in major tournament competition, and became recognizable to audiences as Jeff Cobb rather than through a heavily altered character identity. Because of that history, the decision to give him a new WWE name was always likely to draw discussion among fans familiar with his previous work.

WWE’s preference for assigning new names to incoming talent has often produced a mix of responses. In some cases, a new identity is designed to fit a specific television role or create a distinction from a wrestler’s earlier career. In other cases, performers with significant name recognition elsewhere have retained the names audiences already know. Cobb’s account offers a look at the volume of possibilities that can be involved before a final choice is made.

His comments also underscore the unusual nature of ring-name branding in modern wrestling. A name can have personal history, promotional value, and legal considerations, particularly when it has been used across multiple companies. The fact that JONAH had been associated with Bronson Reed in NJPW, TNA, and PROGRESS added another layer to what otherwise may have been a routine internal naming suggestion.

Would JONAH Have Created Complications?

Cobb did not take the name, so the question remained hypothetical. It is unknown whether using JONAH for him in WWE would have created any legal issues for either Cobb or the company. The available details do not establish who controlled the name or whether any formal rights questions would have emerged.

Even apart from possible legal concerns, there would have been obvious practical issues. Wrestling audiences who followed Reed’s work after his 2021 WWE release would likely have associated JONAH with him immediately. NJPW viewers had seen the name used in a high-profile setting, while fans of TNA and PROGRESS had also encountered it. Giving the same name to Cobb while Reed was back in WWE as Bronson Reed could have created confusion, particularly among viewers who watched multiple promotions.

At the same time, professional wrestling has a long history of names being reused, altered, or reassigned. The surrounding circumstances are what made this case distinctive. It was not a name from a distant era or a loose coincidence. It was tied to a current WWE talent’s recent career outside the company, and Cobb was aware of that connection as soon as he saw it.

Cobb’s story does not suggest that the JONAH proposal advanced beyond the list he was shown. Instead, it appears to be an example of the broad range of possibilities considered when WWE was preparing his presentation. His description of the first page, with names seemingly influenced by Guam and Hawaii, indicates there was at least an effort to connect some options to his background. The JONAH suggestion, in contrast, was memorable precisely because it appeared disconnected from that approach.

Cobb’s WWE Chapter Has Ended

JC Mateo’s WWE tenure is now over. Cobb was let go by WWE in May 2026, ending a run that began with his Backlash 2025 debut. He has since returned to NJPW, the promotion where he had spent much of the period from 2017 through 2025 establishing himself as one of the more imposing heavyweight wrestlers on the roster.

The move back to New Japan places Cobb once again under the name that has defined the bulk of his career. For fans, that continuity matters. Jeff Cobb carries a history built over years in different markets, and his return to NJPW reconnects him with a setting where that identity already has a strong foundation.

His recollection of the WWE name list also provides a small window into an often unseen part of a wrestler’s transition between promotions. The eventual choice of JC Mateo may have been only one outcome among many. In another version of events, Cobb might have arrived with a name tied to Guam or Hawaii. In a far stranger version, he could have been introduced as Jafar Smash or as JONAH, a name many fans already connected with Bronson Reed.

Instead, the JONAH idea remained just that: an option on a page that made Cobb laugh. With Cobb now back in NJPW, the story stands as a curious footnote from his WWE period and a reminder that a wrestler’s on-screen identity can change dramatically before they ever walk through the curtain.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Darryl Polo is a passionate wrestling fan covering WWE, AEW, TNA and beyond. He loves great rivalries, breakout stars and the moments that keep fans talking long after the bell. How we work.