Team USA’s search for a fifth member heading into WWE Survivor Series took several unexpected turns on WWE SmackDown, and it ended exactly where it began: with Cody Rhodes and CM Punk still needing an answer.
What initially looked like a straightforward reveal became a sequence involving WWE Hall of Famer “Hacksaw” Jim Duggan, United States Champion Trick Williams, rapper Lil Yachty, Damian Priest, and SmackDown General Manager Nick Aldis. By the end of the show, neither Duggan nor Williams was positioned to represent Team USA, while Danhausen made an unsuccessful pitch of his own.
Rhodes ultimately said that the identity of the final member will be known by WWE Raw on Monday. The statement provides a deadline for the decision, but it does not clarify whether Rhodes and Punk are already aligned on a candidate or whether the co-captains remain divided over their choices.
Punk’s Announcement Surprises Cody Rhodes
The question of Team USA’s final spot was addressed after Rhodes indicated that he still needed to make a call. Before he could provide a definitive answer, Punk came to the ring with an announcement of his own.
For more background on this topic, read Johnny Gargano Explains Why WWE’s Storytelling Drew Him Back After 2021 Exit.
Punk said he had narrowed the choice down to one person. Rhodes then joined him and immediately questioned what Punk was doing. Punk’s selection was Duggan, the longtime WWE favorite and the winner of the inaugural Royal Rumble match.
Duggan entered carrying his trademark 2x4, giving the moment the feel of a patriotic Team USA reveal. Rhodes, however, was visibly surprised by Punk’s decision. He pulled Punk aside and raised the practical issue: Duggan could not be cleared to compete because he has one kidney.
Punk argued that Duggan’s status as the first Royal Rumble winner was “qualification enough.” It was a characteristically emphatic defense from Punk, one rooted less in medical clearance or present-day competition and more in Duggan’s history, reputation and connection to the Team USA theme.
Rhodes eventually appeared to go along with the idea. He declared Duggan the fifth man on the team, briefly making the Hall of Famer the apparent choice for Survivor Series.
Team Mexico Footage Changes Duggan’s Mind
That apparent resolution did not last long. Punk played a sizzle reel for Team Mexico, revealing the opposition that Team USA would be preparing to face. The footage prompted an immediate and memorable reaction from Duggan.
Looking overwhelmed by what he had seen, Duggan shouted, “NOOOOO!” He then handed his 2x4 to Punk and exited the ring, ending his extremely short-lived stint as Team USA’s fifth member.
The segment balanced the nostalgia of Duggan’s appearance with the broader story of how imposing Team Mexico has become. It also made clear that Punk’s attempt to solve the lineup issue on his own had not succeeded, even after Rhodes had reluctantly accepted it.
Duggan’s departure restored the uncertainty around the final place. More importantly, it emphasized that Team USA’s challenge is not simply filling a spot with a recognizable name. The team needs someone prepared to compete against the group awaiting them at Survivor Series.
Trick Williams Makes His Case
With Duggan out of the equation, the focus shifted quickly to Williams. The United States Champion arrived with Lil Yachty, who endorsed Williams as someone capable of being the “face of Team USA.”
Williams had an obvious case on paper. As United States Champion, he entered the night carrying championship status and a platform closely tied to the identity of Team USA. Rhodes and Punk appeared receptive to the idea, and the segment ended with Williams and Lil Yachty sharing a celebratory moment with the two co-captains.
For a brief period, it seemed that the mystery had been resolved again. Williams was not formally presented as the definitive fifth member before his match, but the reaction from Rhodes and Punk strongly suggested that he had moved to the front of the line.
That momentum was interrupted later in the night when Williams faced Damian Priest. The match did not produce a conventional finish. Priest used the ring bell to attack Williams’ knee, leading the referee to call for the bell.
The attack immediately placed Williams’ Survivor Series status in serious doubt. It was subsequently revealed that the United States Champion would likely be unable to compete at the event, removing him from consideration at a time when he seemed close to joining the team.
Damian Priest’s Attack Has Consequences Beyond One Match
Priest’s use of the ring bell ensured that the Williams situation became more than a missed opportunity for Team USA. Williams’ knee was the specific target, and the post-match indication that he likely will not be able to compete adds immediate concern around the United States Champion.
WWE did not establish a final medical timetable for Williams during SmackDown. The important point coming out of the show is that his availability for Survivor Series is now unlikely, rather than confirmed. That distinction leaves some uncertainty about his condition while still taking him out of the immediate discussion surrounding Team USA’s open spot.
The outcome also changes the tenor of the search. Duggan’s exit was played for shock and humor, but Williams’ removal came after a physical attack. Rhodes and Punk now have to identify a new teammate while knowing that the opportunity may attract attention from competitors looking to make a statement, and that a single confrontation can quickly alter their plans.
For Priest, the attack disrupted both Williams’ championship momentum and a potentially major Team USA role. Even without a traditional result to their match, Priest made his presence felt in a way that could carry forward beyond this episode of SmackDown.
Nick Aldis Sends Rhodes and Punk Back to Work
After Williams was ruled unlikely to be available, Aldis delivered the official instruction to the Team USA co-captains: find another member.
The directive put Rhodes and Punk back at square one. Their partnership has produced an entertaining but unstable process so far. Punk took it upon himself to announce Duggan, Rhodes objected on clearance grounds, and then both men appeared ready to embrace Williams before Priest’s attack changed matters.
Now the two stars need to make a final decision under a compressed timeline. Rhodes’ role in the closing development was particularly notable. He did not name a replacement on SmackDown, but he told Punk that everyone would know the fifth member by Raw on Monday. Before making that promise, Rhodes asked Punk just how much he wanted to win.
That question may prove central to the eventual reveal. It suggests Rhodes is looking for a selection based on more than presentation, popularity or symbolic value. With Survivor Series approaching and Team Mexico already established as a formidable opponent, Team USA’s final member will need to meet the competitive stakes of the match.
Danhausen Offers Himself Up for the Role
One possible candidate attempted to enter the conversation before SmackDown went off the air. Danhausen pleaded his case to Punk, seeking consideration for the fifth spot.
There was no indication that Rhodes or Punk accepted Danhausen’s pitch. Instead, Rhodes’ promise that the answer will be revealed on Raw left the situation open. Danhausen’s approach nevertheless confirms that the vacancy is being viewed as a valuable opportunity, especially with a place alongside Rhodes and Punk on the line.
Whether Danhausen remains a serious possibility is unknown. What is certain is that neither Duggan’s patriotic return nor Williams’ championship credentials produced a lasting solution. One left after seeing Team Mexico’s presentation, while the other was likely sidelined by Priest’s attack.
SmackDown therefore closed with Team USA still incomplete. Rhodes and Punk have a clear assignment from Aldis, a stated deadline of Raw, and a major Survivor Series matchup waiting ahead. The fifth-member reveal now becomes one of the immediate questions heading into Monday’s show, with Team USA needing not merely a replacement, but a teammate capable of helping them win.



