Johnny Gargano’s return to WWE in August 2022 was not simply the end of a brief break from the ring. It was the result of a decision shaped by family, timing and, above all else, a renewed reminder of why he wanted to become a professional wrestler in the first place.
Gargano allowed his WWE contract to expire in 2021 and spent more than half a year away from the company. At the time, he was a free agent while his wife, Candice LeRae, was pregnant. Rather than immediately move to another promotion or rush into a new deal, Gargano stepped back from television and considered what he wanted the next chapter of his career to be.
Speaking on Busted Open Radio, Gargano explained that the emotional side of wrestling is what has always driven him most. Watching the buildup to Shawn Michaels versus The Undertaker, paired with Kate Bush’s “Running Up That Hill,” reminded him of the kind of storytelling that had originally captured his imagination. That viewing experience helped settle his decision: WWE was where he believed he could take part in the sort of major, character-based stories that matter most to him.
The reflection is significant because Gargano’s career has long been closely tied to emotionally layered rivalries and relationships. His most celebrated work has not been defined only by wins, championships or match quality. It has also centered on investment in characters, friendships, betrayals, comebacks and the idea that a match means more when an audience understands what is at stake for the people involved.
For more background on this topic, read GCW Revives Bloodsport With 32-Man Gauntlet to Glory Tournament.
A Break That Created Perspective
When Gargano’s contract expired in 2021, he was one of the most recognizable names associated with WWE’s NXT brand. He had become a foundational figure during a pivotal era for the brand, building a reputation as a performer capable of delivering in high-pressure singles matches, tag team bouts and long-form rivalries. His work with Tommaso Ciampa, in particular, became inseparable from his WWE identity.
But the period away from WWE gave Gargano a different perspective. His absence was not framed as a conventional wrestling departure with an immediate next destination. Family was a major priority, and the time out of the public spotlight allowed him to approach his future without the urgency that frequently accompanies contract discussions in the industry.
That context helps explain why storytelling became such a central part of his answer. Gargano did not describe his return in terms of a single match, a business opportunity or a particular opponent. Instead, he pointed to the emotional scale of WWE presentation and the effect that a carefully constructed rivalry could have on him as a viewer.
For performers, there is often a difference between wanting to wrestle and wanting to be part of a larger narrative. Gargano’s comments placed him firmly in the latter category. The Michaels and Undertaker material reminded him that wrestling can build toward moments that resonate beyond a finish, using history and emotion to give the audience a reason to invest.
The #DIY Reunion Became the Immediate Next Step
Once Gargano returned in August 2022, his history with Ciampa quickly became a central element of his WWE direction. The two reunited as #DIY, restoring one of the most important partnerships of Gargano’s career. Their bond had previously provided WWE with both an acclaimed tag team and the emotional foundation for an intense rivalry, making the reunion a natural way to reintroduce Gargano to the audience.
The #DIY run continued for several years, giving Gargano and Ciampa the opportunity to add another chapter to a partnership that had already carried substantial meaning. Their connection was never just a matter of two wrestlers sharing a corner. The team’s appeal rested on an established history: longtime allies whose success and conflict had both become defining parts of their individual paths.
That history made Ciampa’s departure from WWE early in 2026 particularly important for Gargano’s on-screen presentation. Rather than treating the change as a minor roster adjustment, WWE incorporated the loss into Gargano’s character. Without his longtime friend and tag team partner alongside him, Gargano was depicted as depressed and struggling to find direction.
It was an angle that fit the themes Gargano highlighted during his discussion of storytelling. His connection with Ciampa had been built across years of shared experiences, so the absence had weight. The emotional response was not disconnected from prior events; it drew on the audience’s knowledge of what #DIY had represented.
From the Slump to a Championship Opportunity
In recent months, Gargano has begun to emerge from that difficult period. A key turning point came when he challenged CM Punk for the Undisputed WWE Championship on SmackDown. Gargano did not win the title, but the match served a larger purpose in his character’s trajectory.
A defeat in a championship match can either reduce momentum or provide a performer with a renewed sense of purpose. In Gargano’s case, the Punk match became the catalyst for a more active role on WWE television. Rather than remaining defined by the loss of Ciampa and the depression that followed, Gargano has been presented as someone moving forward again.
That development is especially notable given the way Gargano has historically connected with fans. He has often been at his most effective when positioned as a wrestler who absorbs setbacks, confronts emotional obstacles and keeps fighting for the next opportunity. The result against Punk did not change, but the match created an opening for Gargano to reestablish himself as a relevant presence on the blue brand.
Since then, he has continued to appear prominently on SmackDown and has formed an alliance with current champion Sami Zayn. The pairing gives Gargano another significant relationship to explore while also keeping him close to the championship picture. Zayn, like Gargano, has built much of his connection with audiences through personality, resilience and story-driven conflict, making the association a potentially meaningful one for both characters.
Why Gargano’s Comments Matter Now
Gargano’s explanation for returning to WWE arrives at a point when his on-screen role is again gaining definition. After the end of his latest #DIY chapter and the emotional fallout from Ciampa’s exit, he is no longer presented as a wrestler stuck in the same place. The Punk title match and his alliance with Zayn have created forward movement.
His comments also offer a clear lens through which to view his WWE career. Gargano is not only interested in appearing on a major stage; he is drawn to the process of building stakes over time. The Shawn Michaels and Undertaker buildup that affected him was a reminder that major wrestling stories can make viewers feel the significance of every interaction before the bell rings.
That principle has been visible throughout Gargano’s own WWE journey. His partnerships have mattered because they were allowed to develop. His rivalries have mattered because they carried history. His setbacks have mattered because they were not always immediately discarded in favor of the next match. Even his recent resurgence has been framed around recovery from a personal and professional loss, rather than appearing out of nowhere.
There remains uncertainty about exactly where Gargano’s alliance with Sami Zayn will lead, or whether his renewed momentum will produce another championship opportunity. What is clear is that Gargano has found his footing again after a difficult on-screen year. His return to WWE was motivated by the prospect of telling stories with emotional consequence, and his current position gives him another chance to do precisely that.
For Gargano, the memory of a classic WWE narrative helped bring him back after his 2021 contract expiration. Years later, his path continues to be shaped by the same belief: the biggest matches become truly meaningful when the audience has a reason to care about the journey leading to them.



