A new filing in the battery case involving WWE wrestler Marcel Barthel, who performs as Ludwig Kaiser and has also been identified as El Grande Americano, details the injuries allegedly claimed by Richard Reap following an incident in April 2026.

Reap, described in the case as the alleged victim, claims he suffered a torn rotator cuff and a concussion as a result of the incident underlying the prosecution. The allegations were included in connection with an effort by Barthel’s defense team to obtain Reap’s medical records as the case proceeds.

The filing does not establish that the alleged injuries were caused by Barthel, nor does it represent a judicial finding on the underlying battery allegation. It outlines the defense position that the requested records are relevant to preparing its case and evaluating the claims being made against the WWE performer.

Defense Seeks Records Connected to Claimed Injuries

The requested subpoena is directed at obtaining medical documentation related to the diagnosis, evaluation, and treatment of injuries Reap attributes to the April 2026 incident. The defense is seeking material spanning from April 23, 2026, through November 12, 2026.

For more background on this topic, read John Cena Clarifies WWE Wardrobe Shift: ‘The Jorts Are Retired’.

In the filing, the scope of the requested records is described as covering the alleged shoulder and head injuries, including the torn rotator cuff and concussion. The materials sought include records from emergency treatment, doctors, nurses, diagnostic providers, and consultations, as well as discharge paperwork, referrals, and billing documents.

“The requested subpoena would direct Mr. Reap to produce his medical records relating to the diagnosis, evaluation, and treatment of the injuries he allegedly sustained in the incident underlying this prosecution. The requested records include relevant emergency department records, physician and nursing notes, diagnostic reports, imaging reports, consultation records, discharge instructions, referrals, and billing records from April 23, 2026, through November 12, 2026. The subpoena would be limited to records concerning the alleged torn rotator cuff, concussion, head injury, shoulder injury, or other injury that Mr. Reap attributes to the charged incident.”

The language of the request is significant because it seeks records specifically tied to injuries Reap allegedly links to the charged incident, rather than a broadly open-ended collection of his medical history. Whether the subpoena will be granted, limited, challenged, or otherwise addressed by the court was not detailed in the filing information currently available.

What the Filing Does and Does Not Say

The new material adds medical allegations to the public record surrounding the case, but it should not be treated as a final determination regarding either the injuries or the criminal charge. Reap’s claimed torn rotator cuff and concussion are allegations associated with the prosecution. The defense request for records is part of the legal process through which each side can prepare to argue its position.

Medical records can be important in a battery case for several reasons. They may be used to examine when a person sought treatment, what symptoms were documented, which diagnoses were made, what testing was performed, and whether treating providers recorded a connection between an injury and a particular event. They can also potentially become relevant to questions regarding the severity, timing, and treatment of claimed injuries.

At the same time, a request for medical records does not itself prove that a claimed injury occurred in the manner alleged, and it does not disprove it. The significance of any records would depend on the contents of those documents, the arguments made by the parties, and decisions by the court about what evidence may be obtained or used.

The available filing language specifically references potential documentation such as emergency department records, physician and nursing notes, diagnostic and imaging reports, consultation records, discharge instructions, referrals, and billing records. The defense contends that access to this information is vital to case preparation.

Alleged April Incident Remains at the Center of Case

The case stems from an alleged incident in April 2026. The filing’s requested date range begins on April 23, 2026, suggesting that the defense is seeking documentation beginning around the time Reap says he was injured and continuing through November 12.

No additional factual account of the alleged incident was set out in the information provided with the filing excerpt. As a result, the public record described here does not provide a full narrative of what the parties contend happened, nor does it offer details about any witness testimony, surveillance material, police evidence, or other evidence that may be involved in the prosecution.

The legal matter concerns Barthel in his personal capacity, though he is widely known to WWE audiences under the Ludwig Kaiser name. Like any defendant facing a criminal allegation, Barthel is entitled to contest the accusation and pursue evidence he believes is material to his defense. The charge remains an allegation unless and until it is resolved through the legal system.

Why the Medical-Records Request Matters

Discovery disputes and subpoenas can become major procedural issues in cases where physical injuries are alleged. A prosecution may rely on claimed injuries as part of its account of an incident, while a defense may seek the underlying documentation to independently review the diagnosis, treatment history, reported symptoms, and any professional observations contained in the records.

In this instance, the request is framed around injuries Reap attributes to the charged incident. That focus could allow the defense to assess records related to the claimed torn rotator cuff, concussion, head injury, shoulder injury, and any other injury Reap says arose from the encounter.

Potentially relevant records could include imaging results related to a shoulder injury, notes from medical personnel regarding symptoms associated with a concussion or head injury, instructions provided upon discharge, and referrals for further evaluation or treatment. Billing documentation can also be sought in litigation because it may help establish the nature and timeline of medical services claimed.

However, access to medical information is often governed by legal protections and privacy concerns. Courts may weigh the relevance of requested records against the scope of the request and any confidentiality issues before deciding how to proceed. The filing excerpt does not state whether Reap or prosecutors have objected to the subpoena request, and no ruling was included in the information available.

No Resolution Announced

There has been no announced resolution in the battery case based on this filing. The document represents a development in the pretrial process, not a verdict, plea, dismissal, or sentencing outcome.

For WWE fans, the case is separate from any storyline presentation involving Kaiser or the El Grande Americano identity. The filing concerns an active legal matter and allegations that remain subject to the court process. It is important to distinguish between the public allegations described in court paperwork and any final adjudication of criminal responsibility.

The most immediate issue raised by the new filing is whether Barthel’s defense will be able to obtain the requested medical material, and under what terms. If records are produced, their contents could become a point of dispute as the case moves forward. If the request is narrowed or denied, the defense may need to pursue other avenues in preparing its response.

Further developments could include a court decision on the subpoena, motions from either side, additional filings addressing the alleged injuries, or an eventual outcome in the underlying battery case. Until then, Reap’s claims of a torn rotator cuff and concussion remain allegations presented in connection with the prosecution, while Barthel and his defense retain the right to challenge the claims and the evidence supporting them.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Darryl Polo is a passionate wrestling fan covering WWE, AEW, TNA and beyond. He loves great rivalries, breakout stars and the moments that keep fans talking long after the bell. How we work.