Kacy Catanzaro looks back on her championship history in WWE with a clear appreciation for the journey that led to it. While Catanzaro did not win a singles title during her time with the company, her partnership with Kayden Carter produced two important tag team championship reigns, first in NXT and later on WWE’s main roster.
Catanzaro and Carter held the NXT Women’s Tag Team Championships for 186 days. Less than a year after that reign ended, the pair went on to capture the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championships, holding those titles for 39 days. Speaking in a recent interview, Catanzaro focused on the significance of the NXT victory and why the manner in which it unfolded mattered as much as the championship itself.
“I remember both times,” Catanzaro said. “When it was in NXT, I remember them saying with NXT, it was like, ‘We really want to get to the point where the people really want it for you.’”
A Championship Win Built Through Repeated Setbacks
For Catanzaro, the key to the NXT title win was that it was not presented as an immediate reward. She described Carter and herself being put in the championship conversation repeatedly, only for the breakthrough to remain out of reach. That pattern of near-misses became part of what made the eventual title change resonate with both the performers and the audience following their work.
For more background on this topic, read Zilla Fatu Details John Cena Classic Gift Package Following NXT Invitation.
“In NXT, it was like so many times we were in that story and we just kept not making it, kept not making it,” Catanzaro said. “I’m really glad the way it happened because when we finally did it was just so worth it.”
That distinction is important in a division built around weekly television storytelling. A title reign can establish a team’s place in the division, but the chase often determines how strongly supporters invest in the result. Catanzaro’s comments point to a creative approach that prioritized anticipation rather than simply informing the team that a championship opportunity would be successful.
In wrestling, performers may know the destination of a storyline ahead of time, but that does not automatically create the emotional payoff that viewers see on screen. Catanzaro acknowledged that tension directly. Being told a title win is coming can be meaningful, but she emphasized that the response from the crowd and the sense that fans had traveled through the setbacks with the team changed the experience.
“It’s hard because when someone tells you that you’re going to get something, it’s like, ‘Okay, they’re just saying you’re getting it,’” Catanzaro said. “But to feel from the crowd and the people on the journey with you that you’ve earned it.”
The Carter and Catanzaro Partnership Produced Two Title Reigns
The championship records underline the success of the Carter and Catanzaro pairing. Their NXT Women’s Tag Team Championship reign lasted 186 days, giving the team a substantial run as titleholders in the brand’s women’s tag division. Their later WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship run lasted 39 days, adding a main-roster title to their shared résumé.
Those two reigns are the championship highlights of Catanzaro’s WWE career. Although she never captured a singles championship, the tag title victories reflected the value of a partnership that had developed over time. The two wrestlers were not merely placed together for one brief title program; their shared history made the wins part of a larger arc.
Catanzaro’s reflection also makes clear that she sees both title wins as earned opportunities. She did not isolate the NXT reign from the later WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship victory when discussing the work that led to them. Instead, she described both circumstances as moments where she and Carter had put in the effort necessary to justify the trust placed in them.
“I felt like in both scenarios, we had really worked for it,” Catanzaro said. “So it felt really validating to be able to know that they trusted you with that.”
That feeling of validation is often central to championship wins, particularly for teams competing in a division where chemistry, consistency, and credibility all matter. Tag team titles are not only individual accolades. They also represent confidence in the ability of two performers to work together as a unit, carry programs, and give the championships a presence on television.
Why the NXT Title Story Still Stands Out
Catanzaro’s comments show why the NXT victory remains especially memorable to her. A championship win can be remembered for its result, its match, or its place on a performer’s record. In this case, the process appears to be what has stayed with Catanzaro. The repeated failures to reach the goal did not diminish the eventual victory; they made it feel more meaningful when the team finally got there.
Her description of the crowd response is equally telling. WWE storylines are ultimately designed to generate investment from the audience, and Catanzaro said that the team could feel that investment. The sense that fans wanted the win for Carter and Catanzaro was not something she treated as separate from the championship achievement. It was central to why the moment felt legitimate.
That is a useful measure of a successful title chase. The title itself confirms a storyline’s outcome, but a crowd reaction can confirm whether the story connected. Catanzaro’s recollection suggests that the NXT program succeeded because the audience had seen the team continue to pursue the same objective through disappointments rather than receiving a title opportunity without that foundation.
The outcome also carried professional significance beyond the celebration of winning gold. Catanzaro described the championships as evidence that WWE trusted the team. For any wrestler, particularly one who has worked through a lengthy pursuit to reach a title, that trust can be as meaningful as the physical championship belts. It signals that the performers were viewed as capable of representing the division.
A Look Back at a Defining WWE Accomplishment
Catanzaro’s WWE title record may be defined by tag team accomplishments rather than a singles championship, but the details of those accomplishments matter. The 186-day NXT Women’s Tag Team Championship reign and 39-day WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship reign give Carter and Catanzaro a shared legacy across two levels of WWE competition.
More importantly, Catanzaro’s comments frame those reigns as the payoff for persistence. She remembered the moments when the team came close, did not succeed, and had to continue forward. Rather than wishing the NXT title win had happened sooner, she said she was glad with the way it happened because the wait added to the final result.
That perspective gives the NXT victory a lasting place in Catanzaro’s career. It was not simply a scheduled championship change. In her view, it was a moment supported by the work she and Carter had done, the story audiences had followed, and the confidence WWE placed in them once the time came.
Elsewhere in the interview, Catanzaro also praised TJ Wilson for his wrestling mind. Her wider discussion offered a look at the people and experiences that shaped her time in WWE, but her memories of the title win with Carter remained rooted in one central idea: the championship felt special because the journey made it feel earned.
Darryl Polo
Darryl Polo is a passionate wrestling fan covering WWE, AEW, TNA and beyond. He loves great rivalries, breakout stars and the moments that keep fans talking long after the bell. How we work.