Johnny Gargano is ready for a challenge should he earn a place in the Men’s John Cena Classic, and two WWE names stand out as opponents he would be especially interested in facing: Grayson Waller and EK Prosper.

The tournament is shaping up as an opportunity for competitors from across WWE’s brands to test themselves against unfamiliar opposition. With names including Cody Rhodes, Zilla Fatu, and Noam Dar set for the field as of publication, Gargano sees the possibility of representing SmackDown against NXT as an exciting prospect rather than a complication.

When asked about the NXT roster and the matchups that could appeal to him, Gargano pointed first to Waller, the current NXT Champion. Their history makes that potential meeting considerably more personal than a first-time encounter. Gargano also singled out Prosper as a performer who has caught his attention.

“Oh boy, there’s a lot of great talent in NXT,” Gargano said. “I have a long history with the current NXT Champion, Grayson Waller, who has gone down to NXT and done absolutely fantastic work. I hear incredible stuff about him. A lot of guys down there I like. I can mention a guy like EK Prosper, who I’ve seen that has impressed me down there as well. They have a lot of great young talent and a lot of guys that I think are working incredibly hard. So, look, I’m up for a challenge against anyone.”

For more background on this topic, read WWE NXT Viewership Rises to 676,000 on November 17, 18-49 Rating Holds Steady.

Gargano and Waller have unfinished history

A John Cena Classic match between Gargano and Waller would not simply be a contest built around brand representation. The two have already shared significant moments in NXT and WWE competition, giving a potential tournament encounter a foundation that many cross-brand matches do not possess.

Gargano and Waller met in an Unsanctioned Match at NXT Stand & Deliver in 2023. That match established a clear history between the two competitors, one rooted in the sort of intense environment where Gargano has often excelled. An Unsanctioned Match removes the normal framework of a standard wrestling contest, and that prior meeting means any future bout would carry memories of a rivalry that has already gone beyond ordinary competition.

They crossed paths again in 2024, when #DIY and A-Town Down Under were involved in a feud. That program put Gargano opposite Waller in a different setting, with tag team alliances adding another layer to the relationship between them. Gargano’s past with Waller therefore stretches across both singles and tag team situations.

That background gives Gargano’s comments about Waller added weight. He did not frame the NXT Champion merely as a talented name from another roster. He specifically acknowledged their “long history” while also praising Waller’s work since returning to NXT. Should both men enter the John Cena Classic and find themselves on opposite sides of the bracket, the tournament format would provide a high-stakes platform for another chapter in that history.

For Gargano, the appeal is also easy to understand from a competitive perspective. Waller enters the conversation as NXT Champion, while Gargano would be seeking to carry the SmackDown banner. A meeting between them would place championship-level NXT momentum against a veteran performer who knows Waller’s style and has already navigated rivalry with him before.

EK Prosper also has Gargano’s attention

While Waller is the most obvious possible opponent because of their established history, Gargano’s mention of EK Prosper is notable for a different reason. Gargano said Prosper has impressed him, identifying the NXT talent as one of the names he has been watching.

That endorsement reflects the broader point Gargano made about the depth of talent in NXT. Rather than limiting his answer to one familiar rival, he emphasized that there are many wrestlers on the brand working hard and making an impression. Prosper was one of the specific performers Gargano chose to name.

A Gargano-Proper meeting in the John Cena Classic would present a fresh matchup. Unlike the Waller scenario, the information presently available does not establish a previous major televised rivalry between Gargano and Prosper. The appeal would instead come from the contrast between Gargano’s experience and a rising NXT name whom Gargano believes has stood out.

Gargano has built much of his reputation on his ability to adapt to different opponents and match structures. His response made clear that he is not narrowing his focus to one opponent or one brand. Waller and Prosper may be the two names he raised, but the underlying message was broader: he is willing to face anyone who comes his way in the tournament.

The John Cena Classic could create unusual WWE matchups

Tournaments naturally create possibilities that weekly brand-specific programming may not always offer. The Men’s John Cena Classic has already been positioned with a field that includes Cody Rhodes, Zilla Fatu, and Noam Dar, demonstrating the range of competitors who could be involved.

For Gargano, qualifying for the tournament would put him into a field where preparation cannot be centered around one division or one familiar group of opponents. It could mean confronting a top name from SmackDown, a standout from NXT, or another entrant with a completely different approach to the ring.

The prospect of representing SmackDown is central to Gargano’s interest. Brand pride is often an important ingredient in WWE’s inter-brand contests, but Gargano’s remarks did not sound like empty promotional talk. He paired that desire to represent SmackDown with genuine praise for what he has seen from NXT, including Waller’s current run and Prosper’s development.

There is also a practical competitive element to the tournament setting. Facing a current champion such as Waller would give any entrant a difficult assignment. Facing a younger talent such as Prosper would bring a different kind of uncertainty, particularly when Gargano has publicly stated that he has been impressed by what Prosper has shown.

Gargano did not predict that either match would happen, nor did he claim a spot in the field. His comments were conditional: if he is able to secure a place in the John Cena Classic, he would welcome the opportunity. At this stage, Waller and Prosper are possibilities Gargano would embrace, not confirmed opponents.

Gargano’s message is simple: bring on the challenge

The strongest takeaway from Gargano’s comments is his openness to the entire field. He clearly has interest in revisiting his history with Waller. He also sees potential in stepping into the ring with Prosper. But he closed by making it clear that he is not looking past anyone else who may stand across from him.

That approach fits the stakes of a tournament bearing John Cena’s name. Advancing in any tournament requires more than one favorable matchup, and a competitor must be ready for changing opponents, styles, and circumstances. Gargano’s experience makes him aware of that reality, while his comments show that he is eager for the opportunity rather than hesitant about the unknown.

Waller’s position as NXT Champion makes him a natural measuring stick for any SmackDown representative. Prosper’s momentum and the positive impression he has made offer another compelling route for a potential inter-brand showdown. And with Cody Rhodes, Zilla Fatu, and Noam Dar among the names set for the Men’s John Cena Classic as of publication, Gargano would have no shortage of possible challenges if he joins the field.

For now, Gargano has placed two NXT names on the radar while leaving the door open to every other possibility. If the John Cena Classic gives him the opportunity to compete, he intends to represent SmackDown—and he is prepared for whatever opponent the bracket provides.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Darryl Polo is a passionate wrestling fan covering WWE, AEW, TNA and beyond. He loves great rivalries, breakout stars and the moments that keep fans talking long after the bell. How we work.