Eric Bischoff has delivered a blunt verdict on one of professional wrestling’s longest-running multi-person match formats: he hates battle royals.
The WWE Hall of Famer addressed the subject during an episode of 83 Weeks, where a discussion about WCW’s former World War 3 pay-per-view led to a broader critique of battle royals as a whole. Bischoff, who was closely involved in producing the WCW event from 1995 through 1998, did not frame his objection as being limited to one company’s presentation or one particular variation of the concept. In his view, the core structure of a battle royal creates a format in which few, if any, of the wrestlers involved can truly shine.
“They absolutely all suck,” Bischoff said on 83 Weeks. “I think all that s** sucks... it sucks because nobody looks good in the process.”
Battle royals have been a fixture of wrestling programming for generations. They can be used to establish a contender, fill out a special attraction, spotlight a wide portion of a roster at once, or set the table for another storyline. The format’s simplicity is also part of its appeal: competitors enter the ring together and are eliminated until one wrestler remains. Yet Bischoff argued that the very elements that make the match easy to understand can make it difficult to execute in a way that presents individual talent at its best.
For more background on this topic, read Elayna Black Says CM Punk’s Best Advice Was to Block Out the Noise.
His central point was that wrestlers who may receive meaningful opportunities in singles or smaller multi-person matches are limited when a ring is packed with competitors. A performer’s character, movement, athletic ability and in-ring identity can become harder to communicate when they are one body among dozens.
“You see guys who are showcased in the ring, women that are being showcased in the ring, they’re given, albeit, short opportunities, three minutes, four minutes, six minutes, sometimes an eight minute match or whatever,” Bischoff said. “But you’re getting an opportunity on television to showcase your character and what you’re capable of doing in the ring, right?”
Bischoff’s argument is not that brief television matches are automatically enough to define a wrestler. Rather, he maintained that even a limited one-on-one or conventional multi-person bout gives viewers a clearer picture of who a performer is and what they can do. By comparison, he believes the crowded nature of a battle royal leaves wrestlers searching for isolated moments amid the chaos instead of working within a focused match.
“You don’t get to see it, that same character,” Bischoff said, turning to the logistical challenge of having an enormous group of people active in one match at once.
That concern was especially relevant to the World War 3 concept. WCW’s event was built around a three-ring battle royal, a presentation designed to look bigger than a standard battle royal by placing a massive field of competitors across three adjacent rings. The concept was unquestionably unusual on paper and gave the promotion a visual that differed from a traditional single-ring match. But Bischoff acknowledged that the execution did not match the promise of the initial idea.
Bischoff said he was the person who came up with the World War 3 idea and that WCW higher-ups responded enthusiastically to it. Looking back, however, he conceded that the concept was stronger as a pitch than as a live wrestling match. That is a meaningful admission from someone whose WCW tenure was associated with pursuing large-scale ideas and attempting to create programming that looked and felt distinct.
World War 3’s three-ring centerpiece was intended to make the battle royal itself feel like an event. The enlarged setup naturally allowed WCW to include a huge collection of wrestlers, but it also multiplied the issues Bischoff now associates with the stipulation. More people, more ring space and more potential interactions may sound like a recipe for spectacle. Bischoff’s view is that those same ingredients can instead make it even harder for viewers to follow meaningful action or for the wrestlers to establish anything beyond a fleeting moment.
“When you’ve got 66 people in the ring or whatever it is, what do they do?” Bischoff said. “They’re walking around and looking for places to kind of squeeze in and create a spot that looks reasonably entertaining on television.”
That assessment gets to the production difficulty behind any heavily populated match. Every participant must be positioned safely, must avoid obstructing major moments, and must find something credible to do while other sequences are unfolding nearby. In a battle royal, not every wrestler can be central to the action at the same time. Some must wait for their designated exchanges, some will be tasked with selling or reacting, and some may spend long stretches simply trying to remain visible without distracting from the story being told elsewhere in the ring.
For Bischoff, that arrangement lowers the standard of what audiences are expected to accept as compelling wrestling television. He argued that the viewer is often asked to watch a prolonged collection of disconnected activity while waiting for the meaningful elimination, the final few entrants, or the post-match development that gives the segment a larger purpose.
“The bar is so f****** low when you get to matches like this, in terms of what actually looks good and what’s acceptable, that you’re watching 18 minutes of drek,” Bischoff said. “You’re watching just 18 minutes of garbage to get to a finish that everybody’s looking forward to that’s going to advance a story.”
His criticism is therefore aimed at both the in-ring experience and the storytelling function of the format. Battle royals frequently exist to reach a particular finish: a winner earns an opportunity, a rivalry is advanced, a surprise elimination causes tension, or a final confrontation creates a clear next step. Bischoff does not dispute that a battle royal can lead to an important storyline beat. His objection is that the road to that payoff is too often filled with action he considers unfocused and visually unremarkable.
The comments also put World War 3 in a revealing light. The WCW pay-per-view was not simply a battle royal placed on a card; the three-ring battle royal was its defining attraction. The format was intended to be a signature event for the company, and the scale of the presentation was central to its identity. Bischoff’s reflection that it worked better as an idea than as an on-screen reality illustrates the risk attached to concepts built around size alone. A larger setting may offer a striking visual, but it does not necessarily guarantee a better match.
Bischoff’s remarks were broad enough to include battle royals featuring either men or women. His focus was not on the specific roster involved, but on what the stipulation does to performers who otherwise receive an opportunity to display their personalities and ring skills. From his perspective, the format prevents that individual presentation from coming through consistently.
Notably, Bischoff grouped battle royals into a category of match types he simply does not enjoy, comparing the discussion to lumberjack matches in the broader conversation. Both stipulations can create an immediate visual: a ring surrounded by wrestlers in a lumberjack match, or a ring overflowing with competitors in a battle royal. But Bischoff’s take suggests that visual density does not equal quality. In fact, he sees overcrowding as the main reason these matches can become less engaging than more conventional bouts.
There is also a practical distinction in his comments between a match that contains a few wrestlers and one that attempts to feature an enormous field. Bischoff referenced wrestlers having three-, four-, six-, or even eight-minute television matches in which they can make an impression. In an oversized battle royal, the amount of time on screen may be longer overall, but the usable time for any one wrestler to make a sustained impression can be far smaller. The match becomes about surviving until the right cue, being involved in a brief planned exchange, or being eliminated in a way that serves the finish.
For Bischoff, that is not enough. He wants the action to give a wrestler room to establish character and ability, rather than reducing much of the field to bodies waiting for space to perform a spot. His assessment was unsparing, but it was also rooted in direct experience with one of wrestling’s most ambitious versions of the battle royal.
World War 3 remains an example of how a promotion can attempt to distinguish itself through an unconventional match presentation. Bischoff’s present-day view, though, is that the concept exposed the weaknesses of the battle royal rather than overcoming them. The approval the idea received before it was implemented did not change his eventual conclusion: the spectacle sounded more exciting in theory than it proved to be in practice.
That retrospective is ultimately the key to Bischoff’s comments. He is not criticizing the format from a distance. He is revisiting a type of match that he helped bring to a major WCW pay-per-view stage, and his verdict has not softened with time. In Bischoff’s estimation, whether it is a standard battle royal or an expanded three-ring version, the match is built around a finish viewers want to see while asking them to endure too much unfocused material to get there.



