Cody Rhodes has pulled back the curtain on the unusual advice CM Punk offered him as Team USA takes shape for WWE Survivor Series.
WWE is building toward a 5-on-5 Survivor Series match between Team USA and Team Mexico, and the rivalry received additional attention on the November 13 edition of SmackDown. During that show, Rey Fenix joined Team Mexico. Elsewhere in the presentation, Punk approached Rhodes with a series of possible additions for the American side and urged him to “keep an open mind.”
Rhodes subsequently shared Punk’s full collection of suggestions, and it was anything but a standard shortlist of active WWE competitors. The names span wrestling history, pop culture, music, fictional characters, and people whose involvement would require a considerable amount of imagination—or, in one case, a substantial financial offer.
View the referenced post on X
The list underscores the playful nature of Punk’s pitch, while also putting the spotlight back on the pending Team USA lineup. At this stage, the exchange itself has established that Punk has ideas about who should represent the United States, but it does not confirm any of his choices for the official Survivor Series team.
For more background on this topic, read Stephanie Vaquer Returns on SmackDown as Women’s WarGames Challenge Is Issued.
CM Punk’s Team USA wishlist
Rhodes presented the suggestions as a list attributed to Punk. It began with a pair of names closely associated with patriotic imagery in professional wrestling: Hacksaw Jim Duggan and Ken Patera.
Punk also proposed Nikita Koloff, though the recommendation came with an extremely specific condition. The suggestion was for “1987 Nikita Koloff,” accompanied by the clarification: “do NOT get 1986 Koloff, would not fit group.” The distinction is a particularly deep-cut nod to Koloff’s differing presentation across those years and demonstrates that Punk’s proposed roster was not simply a random list of famous names.
From there, the ideas became even more unconventional. Jason Voorhees was included with the note, “keep an open mind, loves America.” The fictional horror character is plainly outside the normal range of WWE recruitment possibilities, but the entry fits the deliberately broad and comedic framing of Punk’s suggestions.
Mr. America was another name on the list. The character has a notable place in WWE history and has long been tied to Hulk Hogan, though Rhodes’ post specifically named Mr. America rather than expanding on the identity behind the persona.
Bruce Springsteen also made the cut, but Punk was reportedly careful to eliminate any possible confusion over which Bruce he meant. The note read: “not Dickinson, NOT American.” That caveat points directly to the importance Punk placed on the Team USA concept, even within an obviously humorous set of recommendations.
A.J. Lee named as Punk’s top choice
The most striking wrestling-related entry may have been A.J. Lee. Punk listed her as his “#1 pick,” adding that he did not want to appear to be playing favorites. His full note called for “A.J. Lee (in red/white/blue bikini),” combining a personal preference with the red, white, and blue theme of the team.
Whether the comment was solely a joke, a fantasy-booking suggestion, or simply Punk entertaining himself with a deliberately impossible roster was not clarified. What is clear is that Rhodes shared the entry as part of the complete set of ideas Punk gave him, rather than identifying Lee as an announced participant in the match.
The Patriot was also included, with a necessary warning from Punk: “not Dark or Tom Brandi.” That qualifier distinguishes the intended Patriot from other uses of the name and reflects the running theme of increasingly precise instructions attached to several of his picks.
“Es Gee Tee Slaughter” appeared on the list as well, referencing Sgt. Slaughter through a phonetic spelling. Given Slaughter’s longstanding association with military imagery and American patriotism in wrestling, he is one of the more immediately recognizable thematic fits among Punk’s recommendations.
Undertaker, Cena and a costly comeback idea
Punk’s remaining suggestions continued to blend legitimate wrestling icons with exaggerated conditions. He included Undertaker, specifically requesting “‘Taker w/ Betsy Ross flag duster,” which Rhodes described as Punk’s favorite option. The visual of Undertaker entering in a Betsy Ross flag duster would certainly stand apart from the character’s better-known presentations, but the recommendation reinforces Punk’s interest in fully committing to the national theme.
John Cena rounded out the list. Punk’s note acknowledged Cena’s retirement status while still leaving the door open in his own way: “not retired just need to pay $$$$.” Cena has been one of WWE’s most recognizable American stars for decades, making him an obvious name in a hypothetical Team USA discussion. Still, Punk’s wording made clear that this was a wishful proposal rather than a formal announcement.
There is a pattern across the entire collection. Punk’s recommendations were built around recognizable Americana, major wrestling figures, and humorous technicalities. He did not merely name athletes who could make sense in a 5-on-5 match. Instead, he constructed a fantasy roster that ranged from classic WWE personas to a horror-movie figure and a major recording artist.
Rhodes’ decision to make the list public also adds a lighter dimension to the Survivor Series build. Team competition often brings questions about alliances, leadership, and who can be trusted to represent a side in a high-stakes elimination environment. Punk’s contribution to that conversation was less about conventional strategy and more about the biggest possible interpretation of an American-themed squad.
Team Mexico gains Rey Fenix on SmackDown
While Punk’s list generated attention for Team USA, the November 13 episode of SmackDown provided a concrete development for the opposing side. Rey Fenix joined Team Mexico during the show, giving the international contest another established name connected to the match.
That development makes the contrast between the two sides especially notable. Team Mexico received a direct on-screen addition in Rey Fenix, while Rhodes’ update centered on Punk’s offbeat brainstorming for Team USA. The result is an ongoing discussion around who will ultimately fill out the American team and whether any of Punk’s suggestions will have a meaningful connection to the final group.
Several names on the list are clearly presented in a tongue-in-cheek manner, and there was no indication that WWE had officially added Hacksaw Jim Duggan, Ken Patera, Nikita Koloff, Jason Voorhees, Mr. America, Bruce Springsteen, A.J. Lee, The Patriot, Sgt. Slaughter, Undertaker, or Cena to Team USA. The point of Rhodes’ post was the entertaining scope of Punk’s advice, not an official team announcement.
Still, the exchange accomplishes its purpose in the run-up to Survivor Series. It keeps attention on the Team USA versus Team Mexico match, gives Rhodes and Punk a memorable interaction tied to the event, and invites fans to debate which active WWE names would actually be the strongest choices for the American side.
For now, Rhodes has received Punk’s guidance and has been told to keep an open mind. Based on the list, that may be a requirement before Team USA can get anywhere close to Punk’s version of the ideal Survivor Series lineup.


