Chelsea Green says her dispute with New York City’s Plaza Hotel remains unresolved more than two years after she and fellow WWE performer Maxxine Dupri were allegedly mistaken for escorts while attempting to enter the hotel bar.

Green first publicly addressed the incident in April 2024. At the time, she said she and Dupri had been stopped by security and accused of being escorts. Green subsequently received a formal apology and said the hotel had offered a “make-good” gesture. However, the WWE star later revealed in October 2025 that the offer had apparently been withdrawn or was no longer being honored.

During an appearance on What Do You Want To Talk About? with Cody Rhodes, Green provided a new update and said she still has not been able to use the stay she was allegedly promised. While she made clear that she still likes the landmark hotel, Green was blunt about her frustration with the situation.

“I tweeted a picture of the two bodyguards who told me I was an escort. The sweetest man from the Plaza Hotel called me. Sweet, sweet man. He went on and on about how he was going to train them and he was going to give me a free stay at anywhere in the world. Let me tell you something. Last year, I went to go redeem my free stay and it didn’t exist! He lied. It didn’t exist. I want to stay there at Christmas. I love the Plaza Hotel. I need a Macaulay Culkin moment.”

For more background on this topic, read Damian Priest Reveals Netflix Sought Him Out for Animated Film ‘Steps’.

A dispute that has continued beyond the original apology

Green’s latest comments reinforce that the issue, from her perspective, has never reached the conclusion she expected after the initial apology. Her account is that a representative contacted her after she shared an image of the two security personnel involved and spoke about addressing the matter internally through further training.

More importantly for Green, she said that conversation included a specific offer: a complimentary stay at a hotel location of her choosing. Green’s frustration centers on what happened when she attempted to take up that offer. She said the stay “didn’t exist,” repeating the point for emphasis while telling Rhodes that the promise was not available when she tried to redeem it.

The story has endured because it combines a serious allegation of inappropriate treatment with Green’s distinctly comedic delivery. Green has built a strong on-screen WWE persona around exaggerated self-importance, sharp reactions, and an ability to turn everyday frustrations into entertaining material. But her comments about the Plaza have consistently been framed around a real complaint: that she and Dupri were unfairly profiled and that the proposed remedy did not ultimately materialize.

Dupri was part of the original incident referenced by Green, though Green’s newest update focused primarily on her own conversation with the hotel and her unsuccessful effort to redeem the promised stay. No new statement from the Plaza Hotel was included with Green’s remarks.

Green still wants the Plaza experience

Despite the obvious disappointment in her update, Green said she still loves the Plaza Hotel. Her desired resolution is not especially complicated: she wants to be able to stay there during the Christmas season.

Her reference to wanting a “Macaulay Culkin moment” invokes the Plaza’s association with Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, in which Culkin’s Kevin McCallister stays at the famous Manhattan hotel. The hotel’s holiday identity has long been part of its appeal, and Green’s comments suggest that the original promised stay would have had particular value to her if she could use it during that period.

That timing now carries added significance. The Plaza is scheduled to temporarily close in January 2027 for a major renovation that is expected to last multiple years, with the project projected to run for at least four years. Green’s stated wish to visit at Christmas therefore comes shortly before that planned closure.

For Green, a holiday stay would not simply be a generic travel perk. It is the specific experience she said she hoped to receive after the initial conflict. Her latest account makes clear that she does not view the earlier apology as enough on its own if the make-good offer tied to that apology was never made available.

Why the issue has resonated with WWE fans

Public disputes involving wrestlers often move quickly, especially when they emerge through social media. Green’s situation has remained memorable in part because it was tied to a recognizable location, involved another WWE personality in Dupri, and was revisited over an extended period of time.

There is also an understandable sensitivity around the allegation itself. Green said she and Dupri were characterized as escorts while seeking entry to the bar. Her later comments about training indicated that she was told action would be taken after she publicized the encounter. But Green’s subsequent statements have placed the focus on whether the hotel actually fulfilled the commitment it reportedly made to her.

Her October 2025 update had already indicated that the situation was not settled. The new remarks on Rhodes’ show go further by explaining how Green says she learned the offer could not be redeemed. She described receiving an extensive and apologetic phone call, only to find that the free stay was not in place when she later tried to use it.

Green’s language was pointed when she said, “He lied.” That is her characterization of the failed offer and reflects her belief that the original promise was not honored. The available comments do not provide additional details about the booking attempt, what location Green sought to reserve, or whether there were any later discussions aimed at resolving the issue.

Green’s outspoken personality remains an asset on and off WWE television

Green has become one of WWE’s most reliable personalities when it comes to giving a story a memorable voice. Whether she is working within a match, reacting to an opponent, or discussing an experience outside the ring, she has a knack for presenting a complaint with timing and personality.

That does not mean every subject she discusses is part of an on-screen angle. The Plaza Hotel matter predates this latest interview by years and has been addressed by Green in several stages: the original 2024 allegation, the claimed apology and make-good offer, her 2025 statement that the offer had been rescinded or was unavailable, and now her assertion that a promised stay was not actually present when she tried to redeem it.

The consistency in those updates is Green’s position that the proposed solution was never completed. She has not suggested that she no longer wants the stay; on the contrary, she again said that she wants to experience the hotel around Christmas.

Elsewhere in her conversation with Rhodes, Green also discussed her standards for matches in WWE. The Plaza discussion, however, stood apart as a personal matter with a clear unresolved point. Green remains publicly disappointed by how it played out, while also expressing affection for the hotel itself and its iconic holiday appeal.

What comes next

At present, Green’s latest update does not indicate that a new arrangement has been reached. She said the promised stay had not been available when she sought to claim it, and she did not reveal any subsequent booking, replacement offer, or final agreement.

The approaching renovation closure creates a natural deadline around the holiday visit Green says she wants. If the dispute is to be resolved in the manner she originally expected, the window before the January 2027 closure could be especially relevant.

Until then, Green’s position is straightforward. She says she was given an apology and a promised make-good after the 2024 incident involving herself and Maxxine Dupri. She also says that when the time came to use that offer, it was not there. For a performer known for making sure her grievances are heard, the Plaza Hotel situation remains one complaint that has not yet received the ending she wants.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Darryl Polo is a passionate wrestling fan covering WWE, AEW, TNA and beyond. He loves great rivalries, breakout stars and the moments that keep fans talking long after the bell. How we work.